Ist mein Saatgut bei Ledger sicher oder nicht?

[root_s2yse8vt]

Up

0

Down

::

Ich bin wahrscheinlich die 2657. Person, die diese Frage stellt, aber Vorsicht ist besser als Nachsicht.
Ich habe eine Menge Beiträge über das Update gesehen, das es dem Hardware-Ledger-Gerät ermöglicht, die Seedphrase zu teilen.
Ich benutze den Wiederherstellungsdienst nicht und mein nano x verwendet die neueste Firmware, die angeboten wurde, als ich mein ledger mit ledger live verbunden habe.
Gibt es derzeit eine Software in meinem Ledger-Gerät, mit der ich meine Seed übertragen kann? Wenn ja, wie würde das aussehen. Muss ich die Freigabe meines Seeds manuell genehmigen oder kann es gehackt werden, wenn ich es mit meinem Telefon oder Laptop verbinde, ohne dass ich irgendetwas auf dem Gerät selbst bestätige.
Ich bin kein IT-Experte.

[ModsAreDoreens]

Up

0

Down

::

Your seed is safe as long as you trust Ledger not to screwup for the 15th time

[xen91]

Up

0

Down

::

Here’s my view, only a view…

Ledger devices are closed source devices, so we have to believe what we’re told by the maker. ie we must trust the maker to do the right things by us.

They used to tell us that the seed, once set in the device, could never be extracted…

Now they tell us that they can backup the seed onto there servers after it was created. But we must agree to this and initiate it on the device, before it can be done, therefore offering protection.

This leads some to believe (me as well), if a government agency got hold of a ledger and took it to ledger, whether they could force ledger to get the seed and thus take away the crypto.

If that could be the case, the government agency could perhaps force ledger to teach them how to do this….

All the above is probably a remote possibility and therefore do we need to be concerned about it? Perhaps, if info about seed extraction became leaked…

Also recently a 3rd party picked apart the ledger live software and found it was uploading all our wallet data, balances, addresses etc etc to ledger. To me many people in crypto want privacy, this seems to go against that.

[ghost_62]

Up

0

Down

::

if you are scared ablut seed use MultiversX chain it has an EXTRA layer of security called Guardian means seed is protected by 2FA and every transaction

[Successful-Snow-9210]

Up

0

Down

::

Ledger live is open source as is the recovery service.

[taribor]

Up

0

Down

::

Does a passphrase guard against these concerns?

[Dizzy-Discussion-107]

Up

0

Down

::

Your mnemonic seed never leaves the device.

If you don’t share your mnemonic seed to anyone, you’re safe.

[hobbyhacker]

Up

0

Down

::

As an average user you are safe to use Ledger. If you are on the interpol list with governments hunting for you, then good luck.

[Coeruleus_]

Up

0

Down

::

Ya dude move on

[Autor]

Beiträge